Love. The eternal subject. What is this thing called love, I wondered? Once upon a time I scoured my music library for the folk wisdom about love, filling my old ipod mini with 1,000 or so songs about love and its many textures.
Herewith then: Love, a playlist (spotify version)
I tried to stick to love qua love and focused on the word itself and its ramifications, thus there are only 5 songs about 'lovers' and 4 songs about 'loved' e.g. Bob Marley's Could You Be Loved? and The Impressions' I Loved and I Lost
Similarly, there were 12 songs about loving (You've Lost That Loving Feeling obviously needed to be on this playlist and clearly Minnie Riperton's Lovin' you was essential). A boyish Michael Jackson asking Who's loving you could not be denied.
With some effort, I ended up with 1,032 takes on love (caveat: A Love Supreme came in 4 parts). The playlist amounts to almost 3 days of continuous listening and flows quite beautifully if I might say so.
I tried not to repeat myself in this exercise so there are 866 distinct titles. The constraint of disk space on the fondleslab meant that I couldn't add the hundreds of cover versions of standards like Love for Sale that I have amassed (and only 7 versions of You Don't Know What Love Is made it sadly)
The selections focus mostly on soul, jazz and pop. Hip-hop hardly features (love doesn't sell in hip-hop on the whole, LL Cool J's I Need Love notwithstanding), and reggae features disproportionately (lovers rock being an important facet of that genre, just ask Dennis Brown)
Having amassed this body of love as it were, this corpus of love, that many splendored thing (3 versions), I couldn't help myself and did some rudimentary analysis. Consider these liner notes research on the anatomy of love. Let me tell you about love...
Frequency
The usual suspects who made a career on love shine here: Sade, Anita Baker, Luther Vandross and The Temptations. And Motown looms large, the composers Smokey Robinson and Ashford & Simpson dominate. Also, I was initially suprised that Al Jarreau and Regina Belle had such encylopedic takes on love.
The singularity that is
Barry White is mainly dealt with in a separate playlist. I only included 7 of the 54 songs I have of his that directly addressed love. A monomaniac focus on the topic was a virtue of the walrus of love.
As far as the frequency distribution goes, who opines on love? Who shapes the narrative?
- Luther Vandross - 18 songs
- Prince - 17 songs (or 14 if we omit his duets with Sheila E, Madonna and Nona Gaye)
- Al Jarreau - 13 songs
- Temptations / Chaka Khan / Dennis Brown - 12 songs
- Smokey Robinson / Regina Belle - 11 songs
- Ashford & Simpson / Stevie Wonder / Elton John - 9 songs
- Anita Baker / Sade / Gregory Isaacs / Dwele - 8 songs
- Al Green / Barry White / Alexander O'Neal / Brian McKnight / Keith Sweat / George Benson - 7 songs
- Brenda Russell / The Isley Brothers - 6 songs apiece
Typology
Then to the meat of things. There were 66 songs "of love"
What do these songs of love tell us (skipping for now the 20 explicit by less precise "kinds of" love? e.g. The Sunday kind of love that Etta James sings of
The basics: Look of love, Power of love, Way of love, Mystery of love, Glory of love, Gravity of love, Ritual of love, Game of love
Metaphorical: Freeway of love, Caravan of love, Army of love, Sea of love, Land of love, Bed of love, Prisoner of love
Practical: Mind of love, Test of love, Best of love
Whimsical: Ingredients of love, Seeds of love, Color of love
Emotional: Tears of love, Victim of love, Pains of love
Association
"Love and" - what goes with love? Consider fully 24 companions of love. Al Green obviously has the anthems (
Love and happiness,
Love and affection). The Persuaders famously sang of the
Thin line between love and hate complicating the picture. Love sometimes goes with war (Tamar Braxton) and at other times with peace (per Quincy Jones)
There are also the outliers, including my countryman Ebo Taylor who asks the listener to lend him their ears as he weaves a troubling tale about
Love and death
Characterization
We may be social beasts but love is a matter of perspective and indeed love is personal:
Sweet love, Good love, Slow love, Tender love, Baby love, Real love, Endless love, Lost love, Everlasting love, Tasty love, Emotional love, Self love, Blessed love, Precious love, Lifetime love
There's a naivete in love:
Simple love, Special love, Perfect love, Pure love, 100% Pure love, Superfine love, Fine Fine love, True love, Easy love, Sentimental love
Or think of the stages of love: New love, Old love, Young love, Teenage love, Puppy love, Old fashioned love, First love
Pathologies of love: Secret love, Blind love, Hidden love, Unrequited love, One way love, Unreleased love, Stupid love, Strange love, Crazy love, I'd hate to love you
Arcane takes: Cosmic love, Stone Love, Hysteric Love, Carnival Love, Electric Love, Killer Love, Tough love, Bitter love, Superficial love, Famous love, Lucky love, Shotgun love, Telephone love
Time-bound love: Saturday Love, Weekend Love, Love in the night, or as Roberta Flack notes, Tonight I celebrate my love
Religious love: Jesus is love, God is love (a couple of versions). Opinions are divided on whether the
Higher love that Steve Winwood sings off falls in this category.
Parental love:
The love between me and my kids per Smokey Robinson. The Supremes'
Baby love is euphemistic despite the name on the front
It's about mores and values, some takes are quite spicy: Free love, Sexual Love, Love Triangle, Part time love, Love Affair
But love is complicated:
Love can't turn around per Farley Jackmaster Funk and its celebrated Isaac Hayes sample, indeed we can get into semiotics:
Love is not made in words (Deborah Cox) and
Love is not a word (Peter Cinotti)
Love can also be prescriptive:
Love shoulda brought you home per Toni Braxton or say,
It's gonna take all our love as Regina Belle asserts
And then the defaults: One love, Any love, Typical love, More love, Only love and a couple of versions of Love changes (Mother's Finest and the lovely cover by Kashif and Meli'sa Morgan)
At a loss, 12 artists just go with the single word:
Love, and who can blame them.
- Big City double things up with Love Love
- The incomparable Donny Hathaway is three times exuberant with Love, Love, Love
- Lulu claims with the Rule of Four that Love Loves To Love Love
- As Tall as Lions go over the top with Love, Love, Love (Love, Love)
Perspectives
More analysis, who is the subject of love?
40 songs about "your love"
39 songs "love you"
5 songs "love your"
27 songs "my love"
26 songs "love me"
9 songs "our love"
And on declarative matters:
12 songs "for love", causes of love perhaps
4 songs "love or" alternatives to live (Prince's Love or Money being the funkiest)
33 songs "the love"
24 songs "this love"
Declarations
Then there are the descriptions. There are fully 93 songs explaining what "love is" including a few eye openers:
- Love is a house
- Love is a battlefield
- Love is my religion
- Love is contagious
- Love is like a plague
- Love is medicine
- Love is my drug
Following that social disease theme, it's no wonder that Robert Plant is
Addicted to love
True, there are contradictions:
Love is the answer for Kenny Burrell but for Linval Thompson,
Love is the question
Sade, almost inevitably, chimes in with hard-won experience, namely that
Love is stronger than pride while Roy Ayers claims that
Love will bring us back together.
Similarly, Loose Ends declare
I don't need to love, but for LL Cool J, it's the opposite:
I need love; your mileage may vary
Location
There are 9 songs about finding love, its difficulty and its locations (e.g.
Love on a two way street by The Moments),
The places you find love by Tevin Campbell and Beres Hammond crooning about
Love from a distance
Where Roberta Flack is somewhat coy
Feel Like Makin' Love; Johnny Gill explicitly suggests making Love in an Elevator. No wonder some say they don't make love songs
like they used to?
Obligatory disclaimer, any playlist I make has to flow and move me, hence I included a few songs that you might say are love adjacent per my criteria. Sue me
- Right and a Wrong Way by Keith Sweat - this falls under prescription. The lyric goes "There's a right and a wrong way to love somebody"
- The Lovers and Sentimental from Alexander O'Neal (Jam and Lewis's best interpreter oozes love without trying)
- Between the sheets by the Isley Brothers mostly for the part that goes "Enough of this singing, let's make love"
- Je t'aime, moi non plus Serge Gainsbourg and Jane Birkin after realizing that this was an overly anglophone take on the matter
- Part time lover by Stevie Wonder simply for Luther Vandross's adlibs on the chorus
- Loving you by Tony Toni Tone which, as I've noted previously, puts the contraception in baby making music
- As well as a couple from Prince: Joy in Repetition for the telling phrase (Love me) that prompted the song's title and Adore which is the ultimate love song ("love is too weak to define what you mean to me")
I'll end with sentimental favorites: The Beatles optimistically chiming in with
All You Need Is Love while Brenda Russell sings of
A Little Bit Of Love and, for good measure, Teddy Pendergrass is struck by
Love T.K.O.
There's a
spreadsheet, if you want to wrangle the data for yourself.
But mostly there's
the playlist, do give it a listen.
I'm no expert but hey, I wrangled with the textures of love. Be prepared, they said, so I gave you Love, a thousand so ways. I tried to do my part, let me know what you think.
Love, a playlist (spotify version)
Disclaimer: About 80 songs didn't make it in the journey from YouTube to Spotify
The Adinkra symbol,
odo nyera fie kwan, or "
Love always finds its way home".
See previously:
66 Ways to Franco
File under: music, obsession, love, whimsy, culture, observation, perception, humour, language, analysis, statistics, Observers are worried, toli
Writing log. May 6, 2024